TicketCity has been selling tickets from Austin, Texas since Randy Cohen started it in March 1990, which makes it older than online ticketing itself. It has held BBB accreditation since 1996 and still answers a phone line, 800-918-2612, from 8 a.m. to midnight. Vivid Seats is a different animal: a national resale marketplace with a far larger pool of listings, an app built around a loyalty program, and the volume that comes with being one of the biggest names in the business.
Both sell resale tickets, so for most events you will see overlapping broker inventory at different totals. The decision comes down to selection and price on one side against a smaller, older company with a human on the phone on the other. We earn a commission if you buy through our links. It does not change your price. Fee figures below are marked varies by event wherever neither company publishes a rate.
Inventory and what each site is good at
Vivid Seats lists tickets for nearly everything, from arena tours to regional theater, and in most categories it will have more seats and more price points than TicketCity. That breadth is the main reason to start there. Its listings also appear across partner sites and team pages, so the same pair of seats is often visible in several places at once, all pointing back to the same checkout.
TicketCity is a broker and marketplace that grew up on big-ticket sports: college football bowl games, the Masters, the Final Four, the Super Bowl and similar events where tickets are scarce and expensive. It went online in 1998 and expanded nationally by buying SoldOut.com in 2000 and Ticketsupfront.com in 2002. For an ordinary Thursday concert its selection is thinner than Vivid Seats’, but for a marquee weekend it can surface packages and seats that generic marketplaces do not carry.
Fees and the price you end up paying
Vivid Seats shows an all-in price while you browse, as the FTC fee rule has required of every ticket seller since May 12, 2025. It does not publish a fixed percentage, and the service fee scales with the listing price, so a $500 seat carries a bigger fee than a $50 one. What offsets that is Rewards: one stamp per ticket, and 10 stamps become a Reward Credit worth the average value of those stamps minus taxes and fees, applied to a future order.
TicketCity does not publish its fee rate either, and in the past independent reviewers found its service fees reaching 25% of the ticket price, with a separate charge even for mobile delivery. Those findings predate the FTC rule, so treat them as history rather than a current figure. The rule now obliges TicketCity to show the total including mandatory fees before you commit, with taxes and optional shipping the only later additions. Expand the price breakdown on the listing and compare it with the identical seats on Vivid Seats before you pay.
Guarantees and refund wording
The TicketCity Guarantee promises valid tickets, delivery before the event, seats side by side unless noted, and the tickets you ordered or a comparable upgrade. If any of that fails, TicketCity offers comparable or better tickets, a full refund or a credit. Canceled events with no new date are refunded in full. Rescheduled events are not; your tickets carry over, and TicketCity will help you sell them if the new date does not work. Everything else is final.
One detail from TicketCity’s BBB profile matters: a guarantee refund request has to reach the company within five days after the event, with the tickets returned by a trackable method in that window, and if physical tickets already shipped by FedEx the shipping fee is deducted. Vivid Seats’ 100% Buyer Guarantee reads similarly on validity and delivery, but on cancellations it promises full compensation of the purchase price, less possible restocking fees, or a future-purchase credit at its sole discretion. TicketCity’s cancellation language is the more buyer-friendly of the two.
Apps and tools for picking a seat
Vivid Seats’ app is the better buying tool by a wide margin. It carries the Rewards program, with your stamps, credit balance, level (Rising Star, Super Fan or Icon) and expiration dates under the Me tab, and lets you apply a credit to a new order with one tap. Seat maps and deal ratings are built in, and the app is where Vivid Seats pushes bonus-stamp promotions.
TicketCity has an iPhone app that stores e-tickets and tracks orders, but the website does the real work, and the website looks like what it is: a broker storefront that has been updated rather than rebuilt. Seat maps exist for major venues. There are no seat-view photos and no loyalty program. If you are comparison shopping on a phone, the Vivid Seats app will get you to a decision faster.
Last-minute buying and delivery
Both sell until the event starts, and both guarantees cover on-time delivery, but the delivery method on the specific listing decides whether a same-day purchase is sensible. Mobile transfer and e-tickets arrive quickly; anything listed as shipping or FedEx is not a same-day option. TicketCity’s broker background means a higher share of physical or will-call inventory for premium events, so read the delivery line on every listing. Vivid Seats’ larger pool makes it easier to find an instant-delivery listing late.
Selling and customer support
If you need to resell, Vivid Seats is the clear winner. Its terms are public: free listing, a 10% seller fee off the sale price, payment by PayPal after the event, and a requirement that you deliver the tickets the same way you received them. TicketCity’s selling side is oriented toward brokers, and terms for individual sellers are handled on request rather than on a published page.
Support flips the other way. TicketCity answers 800-918-2612 from 8 a.m. to midnight, plus email and chat, and a company of its size can look up your order while you wait. Vivid Seats has a help center, phone and chat, but its volume means longer holds during big onsales. Independent review scores for TicketCity sit around 3.1 out of 5 across roughly 13,000 Trustpilot reviews, with fees the most common complaint, so the phone line is a convenience, not a discount.
The winner: Vivid Seats
Vivid Seats wins on the things that affect most orders: more seats to choose from, an all-in price from the first screen, a loyalty credit that pays frequent buyers back, and published seller terms. TicketCity has the clearer cancellation refund and a phone line that is answered, which makes it a reasonable choice for expensive, once-a-year events, but not the default.
Choose TicketCity for premium sports weekends such as bowl games or the Masters, when you want to confirm an order by phone, or when its listing beats Vivid Seats on the checkout total.
TicketCity offers (6)Choose Vivid Seats for everyday concerts, games and theater, for the Rewards stamps if you buy often, and whenever you might need to resell through a published 10% seller fee.
Vivid Seats offers (6)