Vivid Seats is the only big US resale site that pays you back for volume. Buy 10 tickets and the 11th is covered by a Reward Credit worth the average price you paid, before fees and taxes. StubHub answers with scale, more than 200 countries and the deepest list of sellers for sold-out dates, and a guarantee whose cancellation remedy is a refund rather than a maybe. Both now show fee-inclusive prices, so the decision comes down to how often you buy and what happens when something goes wrong.
This page compares the two on inventory, the fee math after the May 2025 FTC rule, what each guarantee actually promises, the apps, game-day buying, selling and support. We earn a commission if you buy through our links. It does not change your price. Where a company does not publish a number, we say so and tell you how to check it yourself at checkout.
Where each site gets its tickets
Both are marketplaces, not box offices. Sellers range from a season-ticket holder dumping one game to brokers listing hundreds of seats, and the same broker often lists on both sites at once. StubHub’s advantage is depth. It operates in more than 200 countries and territories, in more than 30 languages, and for a sold-out stadium date it typically shows the longest list of sellers and the widest spread of prices.
Vivid Seats says it works with thousands of ticket sellers, and in our checks it is strongest in US sports, where its listing count often matches StubHub’s for an NFL Sunday or a college rivalry game. For a European festival or a Broadway show six months out, StubHub tends to have listings Vivid Seats does not. Neither is the place to start for a show that has not sold out; check face value first.
Fees after the FTC rule
The FTC’s rule on unfair or deceptive fees took effect on May 12, 2025, and both companies switched to fee-inclusive prices that day. Vivid Seats announced All-In Pricing for its app and website, with the per-ticket price shown before tax. StubHub’s switch was messier: the FTC said the total was missing from initial displays from May 12 to 14, 2025, and in April 2026 StubHub agreed to refund $10 million in fees to buyers from that window.
Neither publishes its buyer fee. StubHub says the fee is a percentage of the listing price, plus a delivery fee for some methods, and third-party reviews of its terms put the buyer fee around 15% to 25%. For Vivid Seats we could not find a reliable published figure, so treat any percentage you read elsewhere as a guess. The only honest comparison is the checkout total for the same section, row and quantity, which takes two minutes with both apps open.
Two guarantees, one important difference
StubHub’s FanProtect Guarantee, as laid out in its July 2026 explainer, promises authentic tickets, on-time arrival, comparable replacements or your money back when there is a problem, and a refund if the event is canceled and not rescheduled. Postponed events are not refunded; the tickets stay valid. StubHub’s terms do allow refunds as StubHub credit at its discretion, valid for 12 months, so read the email that arrives with any cancellation.
Vivid Seats’ 100% Buyer Guarantee reads similarly on validity, delivery and comparable-or-better seats. The difference is cancellations. Its guarantee page says you receive full compensation of the purchase price including delivery charges, less possible restocking fees, and that Vivid Seats may instead offer a credit for a future purchase at its sole discretion. Restocking fees on a canceled concert is not language you want to see. For a postponed show, it offers to help reissue or resell the tickets.
Neither covers a change of plans. StubHub asks you to document a problem at the venue and contact it the same day. Vivid Seats’ claim process lives in its Sales Terms, not on the guarantee page, which is one more click than it should be.
Vivid Seats Rewards and what it is worth
Vivid Seats Rewards is free and lives in the app. Every ticket earns one stamp, and 10 stamps become a Reward Credit worth the average eligible price of those 10 tickets. Eligible price strips out taxes, service and delivery fees, and processing costs, which the program terms set at 25% of what remains, so the credit is worth noticeably less than the totals on your receipts. The cap is 50 stamps, or 5 credits, per calendar year.
Tiers are set by spend: Rising Star from $1 to $399 with credits that last 24 months, Super Fan from $400 to $1,999 at 36 months, Icon from $2,000 to $9,999 at 48 months, and Legend above $10,000 with credits that never expire. Credits can only be spent in the app. StubHub has nothing comparable, so a fan buying a dozen tickets a year gives up real money by staying there.
Apps and day-of buying
Both apps deliver most tickets as mobile transfers that work at the gate the same day. StubHub also handles PDF and shipped physical tickets, which still matters for a handful of venues. StubHub’s app lets you track an event and watch its price move; Vivid Seats’ app is where your stamps, credits and birthday reward live, and the company says the app earns stamps faster through surprise bonuses.
For day-of buying, neither has anything like Gametime’s post-start selling window, but both show fee-inclusive totals, which makes the final 48 hours easy to watch. If you are standing outside the arena, pick whichever app already has your payment details saved. The minutes matter more than the fee.
Selling and support
Neither site publishes a seller fee. Reviews of StubHub’s November 2025 terms cite 10% to 15% taken from proceeds, with a penalty of up to 40% of the ticket cost for failing to deliver. Third-party guides put Vivid Seats’ seller cut at about 10%, paid after the event, but we could not confirm that on a Vivid Seats page. On either site, the listing screen shows your payout before you confirm, so check that number rather than trusting a blog.
Support is where Vivid Seats pulls ahead a little. It lists phone and online support during extended business hours and asks you to start at its contact page. StubHub leans on its help center and a same-day reporting rule. Both resolve the clear failures; both argue the gray ones.
The winner: StubHub
StubHub takes it because the thing a guarantee exists for, a canceled show or a seat that does not scan, is handled with cleaner language: comparable tickets or your money back, a refund when the event dies. Vivid Seats’ restocking-fee clause and credit at its discretion are the kind of fine print that costs people money. Vivid Seats wins only when volume makes the Rewards credit bigger than that risk.
Choose StubHub if you buy a few times a year, the event is sold out or abroad, or you want cancellation language that says refund without a restocking clause.
StubHub offers (6)Choose Vivid Seats if you buy 10 or more tickets a year in its app, since the Reward Credit and tier perks add up to money StubHub never gives back.
Vivid Seats offers (6)